ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

giverny

 

 

Introduction

 

  • Elisha Coy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream

 

elishacoygold

 

 

  • Giverny Real Skinny Premium Magic BB Cream

 

Express silkiness and present you wrinkle care, whitening, UV care at the same time. Triple-functional BB cream.

 

image

 

 

 

Packaging

 

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB CreamElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB CreamElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB CreamElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

 

Ok, both of them have very similar packaging – both have the ‘premium’ tag on their names, both of them uses the gold colour on their packaging. The Giverny comes in a very nice slide-out box and definitely has that premium feel to it compared to the normal box of ElishaCoy.

However, in terms of the pump, the ElishaCoy is more bulky and big compared to the slimmer and taller Giverny BB Cream. I’d say that Giverny definitely fares better in terms of packaging ….but there is one flaw and it is quite a major one. I have no problems dispensing the ElishaCoy Bb Creams, but i do have this problem with the Giverny one. Sometimes i’d have to pump several times and there would still be no BB Cream, and then suddenly SPLOOSH, a huge blob comes out. The ElishaCoy pump also has a smaller hole so it is easier to control the amount of the BB Cream. So… sorry Giverny, eventhough you look gorgeous ..

 

 

Colour / Shade & Texture

 

I took photos in all the possible conditions : under sunlight, under yellow light, under flash so you can see the difference.

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB CreamElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

 

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB CreamElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

 

Though both the shades look extremely similar, there is a slight differences in terms of shade. The Giverny BB Cream is slightly darker than the ElishaCoy – but both of them have a lighter shade. Both also have that pinkish undertone with the Giverny having the heavier pinkish tone.

 

In terms of texture, i LOVE both of them. They have different textures. The ElishaCoy BB Cream has a creamy nice texture yet being able to retain that balmy texture, and i love my BB Creams to have that Balmy texture instead of that liquid foundation texture. Giverny’s BB Cream has a really light yet creamy texture which is so lightweight that it feels like a feather. It’s like a whipcream BB and spreads effortlessly. It is also moist and doesn’t feel dry and despite its whip cream texture, it manages to retain that balm-like texture. Defnitely one of the best lighter textures in a BB Cream out there , and trust me, i’ve tried MANY.

 

Both BB Creams blends effortlessly and is such a pleasure to work with. They both look natural on the skin. I definitely love the texture of the Giverny but i prefer the after-feel of the ElishaCoy as it feels more dewy and hydrating on the skin due to it’s balmy texture. The Giverny has more of a matte finish.

 

Oil Test

 

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

 

I knew that ElishaCoy was going to be way oilier than the Giverny because of it’s balmy and oilier texture which you could immedi
ately feel after applying the BB Cream. True enough ! Photo taken after 8 hours.

 

Adherence / Water Test

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

 

Applied BB Cream to my hands, washed them using water and used tissue to wipe.  The only thing that stops the Giverny from being that perfect BB is it’s adherence. It wipes off easily, so if you’re sweating… try not to use your tissues. Thank god that it doesn’t melt together with water… so as long as you don’t wipe off your sweat with tissues, there won’t be a problem. The ElishaCoy fares much better. Both BB Creams are long lasting .

 

 

Coverage

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB CreamElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

bb

 

I took a photo to see how it could cover pores and acne scars. I didn’t blend them properly so you could see the difference with the natural skin. Both of them have above average coverage and the Giverny fares better despite it’s light and fluffy texture!

 

 

Oxidation

 

ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream

 

Both of them fared pretty well in the oxidation test. The Giverny had slight changes, but nothing too obvious and hardly noticeable!

 

Ingredient List

 

  • Elisha Coy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream

elisha_ingredients

Credits : Sharon

 

  • Giverny Real Skinny BB Cream

정제수
사이클로펜타실록산
티타늄디옥사이드
글리세린
탈크
에칠헥실메톡시신나메이트
피이지-10디메치콘
디프로필렌글라이콜
알부틴
이소에이코산
징크옥사이드
사이클로메치콘
트리에칠헥사노인
디스테아디모늄헥토라이트
헥실라우레이트
토코페릴아세테이트
아르테미아추출물
마그네슘설페이트
C12-14파레스-3
비닐디메치콘/메치콘실세스퀴옥산크로스폴리머
아크릴레이트/디메치콘코폴리머
메치콘
팔미틱애씨드
디메치콘/비닐디메치콘크로스폴리머
베타인
알루미늄하이드록사이드
알루미늄스테아레이트
아데노신
디메치콘
마데카소사이드
부틸렌글라이콜
카보머
팔미토일펜타펩타이드-3
폴리소르베이트20
아세틸헥사펩타이드-8
향료
페녹시에탄올
메칠파라벤
프로필파라벤
부틸파라벤
황색산화철
적색산화철
흑색산화철

Water
Cyclopentasiloxane
Titanium dioxide
Glycerin
Talc
Echilheksilmetoksisinnameyiteu
PEG -10 Dimethicone
Dipeuropilrengeulrayikol
Arbutin
Yisoeyikosan
Zinc oxide
Sayikeulromechikon
Tree aged seven hex
Te Des Moines aluminum disk hectorite
Heksilrawooreyiteu
Tocopheryl acetate
Extract of Artemisia Mia
Magnesium sulfate
C12-14 Gwangju Palace -3
Binildimechikon /mechikonsilseseukwioksankeuroseupolrimeo
Acrylate / dimechikonkopolrimeo
Mechikon
Palmyra ash seed ticks
Dimethicone / Vinyl Crosspolymer D. Cone value menu
Betaine
Aluminum hydroxide
Aluminum stearate
Adenosine
Dimethicone
Caso Madera side
Butilrengeulrayikol
Carbomer
A penta-peptide palmitate Sat -3
Polysorbate 20
Acetyl Hexapeptide – 8
Spices
Phenoxyethanol
Mechilparaben
Peuropilparaben
Butilparaben
Yellow iron oxide
Red iron oxide
Black iron oxide

 

ElishaCoy has the better, cleaner list here without a doubt!

 

Conclusion

 

ElishaCoy

Giverny

Price

$60 SGD

$30 SGD Red heart

Packaging

Red heart

 

SPF

45 Red heart

30

Shade

 

Red heart

Texture

 

Red heart

Oil Test

 

 

Hydration

Red heart

 

Coverage

 

Red heart

Ingredient List

Red heart

 

 

Let me start by saying that i love both BB Creams. They’re definitely above average BB Creams, near excellent. Definitely in the TOP 15 BB Creams.

 

ElishaCoy BB Cream is for :

  • Those with normal to dry skin
  • Those who prefers a balmy texture
  • High SPF
  • Quality ingredients
  • Rich ( lol, since it’s 2 times more expensive but looking at the ingredient list – you kind of understand why )
  • Those looking for a BB Cream with physical sunscreen

 

Giverny BB Cream is for :

  • Those with normal combination oily skin
  • Those who loves a light airy texture and matte finish
  • Those looking for a BB Cream with higher coverage

 

Love this blog and never want it to close down? Do your part in maintaining it ( i need to pay for hosting! ) by clicking on the link below if you are purchasing anything from Cosme-de, or donate! My host has been shutting down my site for a few times and have given me the last warning because of overloading the servers – so if it shuts down one last time, i will be closing down this blog because i can’t afford their premium plan!

Free Shipping on ALL cosmetics products!!






0 responses to “ElishaCoy Premium Gold Mineral BB Cream VS Giverny Real Skinny Premium BB Cream”

  1. hey hope, i noticed some of the english ingredients for the Giverny bb cream aren’t real english words so i’ve translated them for you. no offense on your translation job or anything.

    정제수, 사이클로펜타실록산, 티타늄디옥사이드, 글리세린, 탈크, 에칠헥실메톡시신나메이트, 피이지-10디메치콘, 디프로필렌글라이콜, 알부틴, 이소에이코산, 징크옥사이드, 사이클로메치콘, 트리에칠헥사노인, 디스테아디모늄헥토라이트, 헥실라우레이트, 토코페릴아세테이트, 아르테미아추출물, 마그네슘설페이트, C12-14파레스-3, 비닐디메치콘메치콘실세스퀴옥산크로스폴리머, 아크릴레이트디메치콘코폴리머, 메치콘, 팔미틱애씨드, 디메치콘비닐디메치콘크로스폴리머, 베타인, 알루미늄하이드록사이드, 알루미늄스테아레이트, 아데노신, 디메치콘, 마데카소사이드, 부틸렌글라이콜, 카보머, 팔미토일펜타펩타이드-3, 폴리소르베이트20, 아세틸헥사펩타이드-8, 향료, 페녹시에탄올, 메칠파라벤, 프로필파라벤, 부틸파라벤, 황색산화철, 적색산화철, 흑색산화철

    water, cyclopentasiloxane, titanium dioxide, glycerin, talc, ethylhexyl methoxycinnamate, peg-10 dimethicone, dipropylene glycol, arbutin, isoeicosane, zinc oxide, cyclomethicone, triethylhexanoin, disteardimonium hectorite, hexyl laurate, tocopheryl acetate, artemia extract, magnesium sulfate, c12-14 pareth-3, vinyl dimethiconemethicone silsesquioxane crosspolymer, acrylatesdimethicone copolymer, methicone, palmitic acid, dimethiconevinyl dimethicone crosspolymer, betaine, aluminium hydroxide, aluminium stearate, adenosine, dimethicone, madecassoside, butylene glycol, carbomer, palmitoyl pentapeptide-3, polysorbate 20, acetyl hexapeptide-8, fragrance, phenoxyethanol, mtehylparaben, propylparaben, butylparaben, yellow iron oxide (ci77492), red iron oxide (ci77941), black iron oxide (ci77499)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



© Copyright Hope in a Blog 2017. All Rights Reserved.
Web Design by IIFOLIO
Home            About           Ingredient List           Contact Us